With the combined character rosters of MARVEL and DC, that would be a nigh-impossible task. Not to mention customs.
we would only have to rank the characters that have already been claimed, and then continue to do so when users claim new characters. it'd be hard, but certainly far from impossible.
That would be susceptible to users pushing a character that belongs in the 3rd tier into the 1st tier to stop people from having them, for example.
Such as? And the Amalgam Universe isn’t a mainstream universe. Some fans don’t know it happened.
Mr. Manhattan, One above All, Galactus, Jean Grey, and more that I don’t know off the top of my head.
Just because it’s obscure canon doesn’t mean it should be banned. Comboman and Squirrel Girl are both obscure, but aren’t banned, because they’re canon, along with a multitude of other stuff.
Why should we do this? Well, Drake, before you get your authority shirt on and talk about the old RP, hear me out. We should ban it because it messes everything up. It creates a whole new list of characters, and cancels out old ones. For example, Thanoseid has been claimed by Mr. Venomir. But now, no one can have Thanos or Darkseid. And them combined is incredibly OP. Like most of the Amalgam characters.
Next point, canonicity. The Amalgam Universe has not been given a designation by D.C. Which means it ain’t canon there. MARVEL might’ve, but that isn’t my point. The point is it messes up the canonicity of certain characters. It raises questions about whether or not some characters are allowed. Also, in future, if it is allowed then people will want other universes as well. MARVEL 2099, MARVEL Noir, Injustice, etc.
Final point, the reboot. I asked Drake about this, and he said that the Amalgam Universe was introduced in the old RP. That has been rebooted into the new RP, Project SHaRP. So it is no longer relevant.
Please take this proposal into consideration.
As amusing as that was, you are wrong.
One, my authority shirt is at the cleaners. Thanos and Darkseid and Thanoseid are three completely separate characters in this and the previous RP. The Amalgam universe is a new set of RPCs, not merging the old ones. I don't even want to know how you thought we are allowed to merge our RPCs willy-nilly.
Yes it was. DC Comics published the Amalgam Collection books, and both companies cooperated in the creation of it, as well as the DC v MARVEL story line which preceded it.
This has nothing to do with it. All alternate realities are allowed. All of them WERE allowed. There is no reason to ban them. After all, various Batmans could come in handy. '66 Batman, The Batman, TDK Batman, all of them could be used by users who want to play the role of Batman. Limit the RP to only ONE Batman, you can be sure we'd have issues. We'd have to resort to either picking a character or leaving an RP, or maybe even putting limits on how long a user can hold an RPC, or even ban canon characters altogether.
Easy solutions: Make them claim both characters involved in the fusion first, or simply allow characters from both universes to exist at once. And as for the other universes, Marvel 2099 is a canon marvel line, I don’t see why we wouldn’t include it.
It means OPness of the highest order. Also, 2099 is the far future.
OPness is irrelevant. Like I always way... Anyway, 2099 characters should be allowed as well. Time travel stories are very common in both MARVEL and DC.
Far more OP characters already exist in the Marvel and DC universes. Also, time travel exists too, and has been used quite a bit. There’s no downside from using basic alternate universes that I can think of.
Such as? And the Amalgam Universe isn’t a mainstream universe. Some fans don’t know it happened.
Some fans don't know Batman was a vampire either, but nonetheless, it is canon. Besides, just because some people are ignorant to some facts doesn't mean it never happened.
Why should we do this? Well, Drake, before you get your authority shirt on and talk about the old RP, hear me out. We should ban it because it messes everything up. It creates a whole new list of characters, and cancels out old ones. For example, Thanoseid has been claimed by Mr. Venomir. But now, no one can have Thanos or Darkseid. And them combined is incredibly OP. Like most of the Amalgam characters.
Next point, canonicity. The Amalgam Universe has not been given a designation by D.C. Which means it ain’t canon there. MARVEL might’ve, but that isn’t my point. The point is it messes up the canonicity of certain characters. It raises questions about whether or not some characters are allowed. Also, in future, if it is allowed then people will want other universes as well. MARVEL 2099, MARVEL Noir, Injustice, etc.
Final point, the reboot. I asked Drake about this, and he said that the Amalgam Universe was introduced in the old RP. That has been rebooted into the new RP, Project SHaRP. So it is no longer relevant.
Please take this proposal into consideration.
As amusing as that was, you are wrong.
One, my authority shirt is at the cleaners. Thanos and Darkseid and Thanoseid are three completely separate characters in this and the previous RP. The Amalgam universe is a new set of RPCs, not merging the old ones. I don't even want to know how you thought we are allowed to merge our RPCs willy-nilly.
Yes it was. DC Comics published the Amalgam Collection books, and both companies cooperated in the creation of it, as well as the DC v MARVEL story line which preceded it.
This has nothing to do with it. All alternate realities are allowed. All of them WERE allowed. There is no reason to ban them. After all, various Batmans could come in handy. '66 Batman, The Batman, TDK Batman, all of them could be used by users who want to play the role of Batman. Limit the RP to only ONE Batman, you can be sure we'd have issues. We'd have to resort to either picking a character or leaving an RP, or maybe even putting limits on how long a user can hold an RPC, or even ban canon characters altogether.
we would only have to rank the characters that have already been claimed, and then continue to do so when users claim new characters. it'd be hard, but certainly far from impossible.
That would be susceptible to users pushing a character that belongs in the 3rd tier into the 1st tier to stop people from having them, for example.
i'm not sure i understand. the PAs would rank the characters
